Which fly reel is better 10 pts?

1) http://cgi.ebay.ca/FINALIST-FLY-FISHING-REEL-3-25-7-8-WT-GRAPHITE-175_W0QQitemZ270428431755QQcmdZViewItemQQptZLH_DefaultDomain_2?hash=item3ef6ca658b&_trksid=p4634.c0.m14.l1262

2 and 3 are the same reel.

#2 or 3 would probably be your best bet given the selection. It’s a basic aluminum frame reel. The design has been around forever. South Bend is not known for the best quality, but there’s not to much to mess up on this type of reel.

#1 is a graphite frame reel. The tolerances in these is not always too good. In a 7/8 weight it could make a big difference in how smooth the reel operates. I wouldn’t buy it. Maybe a 3/4 wt for panfish where the reel will only be holding the line, but that’s about it.

#4 Stay Away! I know this company. This one looks much better than it really is.

Ted Juracsik on Tibor Fly Reels – Leland Fly Fishing Outfitters

	DG60LA 3/4 Line Freshwater Plastic Fly Fishing Reel $12.42

	BF600A Aluminum 3/4 Line Freshwater Fly Fishing Reel $18.05

	Aluminum BF800A 5/6 Line Freshwater Fly Fishing Reel Z1 $3.95

	Aluminum BF800A 5/6 Line Freshwater Fly Fishing Reel Z1 $4.95

	BF600B 3/4 Line Freshwater Fly Fishing Reel Brand New Plastic Light Weight Gift $3.25

	House of Hardy Ultralite Disc #6 fly reel 5 – 6 wt line freshwater trout fishing $375.00

	Aluminum BF1000A Line Freshwater Fly Fishing Reel Z2 $4.95

	BF600B 3/4 Line Freshwater Fly Fishing Reel Brand New Plastic Light Weight Gift $0.11

	Fly Fishing Reel 3/4 Line Bearing Freshwater Light Weight Brand New BL43SI $1.25

	BF600B 3/4 Line Freshwater Fly Fishing Reel Brand New Plastic Light Weight Gift $0.01

	BF800A Aluminum 5/6 Line Freshwater Fly Fishing Reel $17.91

	BF1000 Aluminum 7/8 Line Freshwater Fly Fishing Reel $21.23

	Pflueger Fly Kit, 8-Feet 0-Inch $33.50 Pflueger is 8 -feet three piece 5/6 weight fly rod with cork grip, 3 pieces, 2 5/8-Inch spool diameter, 25/32-Inch spool width, up to 7 fly Line 1094 control fly reel 25 yards of level fly line 4X tapered leader braided dacron backing….

	Crystal River Fly Fishing Combo Kit $15.49 Pre-packaged combos make selecting the right equipment for getting started a snap. The Crystal River fly fishing combo kit eliminates the guesswork that can be so intimidating to a newcomer. Features include an EVA foam grip that won’t slip in your hand. Instructions for tying five basic fishing knots and general fly fishing techniques are included….

Pflueger 4730GXX Trion Spinning Reel, 115-Yard/6-Pound $34.99 Features: * 6 Stainless steel ball bearings * One way clutch instant anti-reverse * Smooth Multi-Disc front drag system with stainless steel and oiled felt washers * Lightweight graphite body and rotor * Long cast aluminum spool with titanium lip * Anti-twist titanium line roller * Sure-click bail * Machined aluminum handle with rosewood knob * Spare aluminum spool * Convertible…